Hi,
I have been playing extensively ED1 when it was released, and now after a long pause, I want to GM again on ED4.
One rule change I have noted regarding spellcasting, is that if I remember well in ED1, someone (including the spellcaster when targetting himself) could volunteer to get targetted to the spell, lowering if I remember well its mystical defense to 2, and therefore except Role of One granting automatic success to the spell.
In ED4, I don't see this anymore, and moreover with the addition of "successes" that increase the spell effects, for sure it would imbalance the game. On the other hand, as MD evolves also, i have a hard time imagining spellcasters regularly failing to cast a spell on themselves, or not able to get extra successes as they achieve higher circles, because both their spellcasting and their MD evolved...
What s other GM's take on this aspect ?
Ed4 : Lowering Mystical Defense
- Flowswithdrek
- Posts:45
- Joined:Sun Nov 27, 2016 7:09 pm
- Location:Beheaded In Iopos
Re: Ed4 : Lowering Mystical Defense
Ive had no trouble with being unable to lower Mystic Defence. A few of my players grumbled in the beginning, but soon got used to it and moved on. Casting has only failed a few times and my group has been playing since 4th ED came out. The rules overall seem well balanced.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>My Stuff On DriveThru RPG<<<<<<<<<<<<<
The-Witch's-Daughter-Adventure-Module
100-City Encounters--Adventure Hooks-for-all-fantasy-RPGs
The-Witch's-Daughter-Adventure-Module
100-City Encounters--Adventure Hooks-for-all-fantasy-RPGs
Re: Ed4 : Lowering Mystical Defense
There's an optional rule in the companion 4e for it:
LOWERING MYSTIC DEFENSE
Earlier editions of Earthdawn allowed characters to voluntarily lower their Mystic Defense when casting a spell on themselves, or by a friendly magician. This makes it easier for enhancing spells to take effect. The Lowering Mystic Defense optional rule returns this feature to the game.
When casting a spell on a willing target, the Spellcasting test always scores at least one success. Additional successes are calculated as normal, comparing the result to the target’s normal Mystic Defense.
Re: Ed4 : Lowering Mystical Defense
Thanks for the reply. The optional rule makes sense to me... I have to put it to test ( just going back to the game, so I am still exploring the differences)
-
- Posts:527
- Joined:Thu Feb 28, 2019 8:39 am
Re: Ed4 : Lowering Mystical Defense
i would also mention that some of the new shaman spells in the mystic paths book give a TN of 6 for willing targets, which is another option that could be considered (though you should probably do so carefully).